Graham Johnson's Schubert edition covers all of Schubert's secular vocal compositions with piano accompaniment. However, this volume of the Schubert edition slips in a little Schubert pseudo-sacred music: a hymn to the Almighty, a hymn to the Unending, a pagan lamentation, a pantheistic hymn to the evening and another pantheistic hymn to the stars, three settings of the Psalms (one of which is Schubert's only setting of Hebrew), and a faux-Old Testament oratorio in the style of Handel. In other words, this volume has ...
Read More
Graham Johnson's Schubert edition covers all of Schubert's secular vocal compositions with piano accompaniment. However, this volume of the Schubert edition slips in a little Schubert pseudo-sacred music: a hymn to the Almighty, a hymn to the Unending, a pagan lamentation, a pantheistic hymn to the evening and another pantheistic hymn to the stars, three settings of the Psalms (one of which is Schubert's only setting of Hebrew), and a faux-Old Testament oratorio in the style of Handel. In other words, this volume has everything it needs to succeed as sacred music except for one thing: soprano Christine Brewer. Brewer is a full-throated, deep-chested singer -- a sort of art-song Ethel Merman -- and her interpretations of her songs in this volume are just the other side of sensual and just this side of sexy. But she is still compelling: any singer who can't belt out Die Allmacht (D. 872A) and can't punch out Dem Unendlichen (D. 291) doesn't stand a chance against Schubert's stentorian vocal writing, And...
Read Less
